Home » Articles » Ec article 102 guidelines for writing

Ec article 102 guidelines for writing

Ec article 102 guidelines for writing another because of

Procedures: abuse of dominance

Article 102 within the Agreement across the Functioning within the Eu (TFEU) prohibits abusive conduct by companies that possess a dominant position round the particular market.

Articles 102 situation labored with using the European Commission or maybe a nationwide competition authority can originate either upon receiving the complaint or while using opening in the own–initiative analysis.

Assessing dominance

The Commission’s beginning point in a Article 102 analysis should be to assess once the undertaking concerned is dominant otherwise.

Defining the best market is important for assessing dominance, should be dominant position could only exist round the particular market. Before assessing dominance, the Commission defines the product market along with the geographic market.

  • Product market. the best product market includes all products/services the customer views to get replacement for one another because of their characteristics, the expense additionally for their intended use.
  • Geographic market. the best geographic information mill an area where the conditions of competition for almost any given product are homogenous.

Market shares undoubtedly are a helpful first symbol of the need for each firm available on the market than these. The Commission’s view may be the more business, along with the longer the time-frame it’s held, the extra likely it’ll be an initial symbol of dominance. In situation your organization includes a business of under 40%. it rarely is at dominant.

The Commission also takes additional conditions into consideration inside the assessment of dominance, such as the ease that others can type in the market – whether you will find any barriers with this particular the presence of countervailing buyer power the general size and strength in the organization that is sources along with the extent it’s present at numerous amount logistics (vertical integration).

Ec article 102 guidelines for writing susceptible to fines enforced through

What’s an abuse?

To be a dominant position isn’t alone illegal. A dominant clients are titled to compete across the merits as with all other company. However, a dominant company includes a special responsibility to ensure that it’s conduct doesn’t distort competition. Types of conduct that could comparable to an abuse include: requiring that buyers purchase all units in the particular product only inside the dominant company (exclusive purchasing) setting prices baffled-making level (predation) refusing to provide input indispensable for competition in a ancillary market charging excessive prices.


The Commission’s investigative forces to enforce Article 102 are detailed in Regulation 1/2003 (the Antitrust Regulation). The Commission is empowered, for instance, to:

  • Send information demands to companies
  • Poor an inspection mark:
    • type in the premises of companies
    • see the records associated with the business
    • take copies of individuals records
    • seal the business premises and records within a check mark
    • ask people of staff or company representatives questions regarding the subject-matter and cause of the inspection and record the solutions.

    Ec article 102 guidelines for writing to become with each other

Inside the finish within the initial investigative phase, the Commission usually takes cautious pursue the issue must be priority and to do an in-depth analysis, so that you can close it.

Statement of objections and Article 7 prohibition decision

Transporting out a analysis, the Commission may issue a remark of objections (SO). This document informs the parties within the Commission’s objections elevated against them. It provides the businesses the chance to workout their legal legal legal rights of defence.

Legal legal legal rights of defence. To make sure a goal outcome, the parties receive certain legal legal legal rights of defence. They’re titled to offer the file – what this means is they might see all non-private documents inside the Commission’s analysis. The parties will answer the So on paper within the certain delay. They might also request an dental hearing. that’s conducted by an impartial Hearing Officer. After analyzing the parties’ arguments, the Commission reviews and sometimes abandons (a part of) its initial objections and really should close the issue.

When the Commission’s concerns aren’t – or only partially dispelled – it drafts a choice prohibiting the identified breach (based on Article 7 within the Antitrust Regulation). The draft will probably be printed for that Advisory Committee made up of representatives within the Member States’ competition government physiques. This gives one further sign in the draft decision. If fines are suggested within the draft decision, the Advisory Committee meets again to particularly discuss them. Finally, it’s printed for that College of Commissioners which adopts the choice.

Article 9 commitment decisions

Alternatively, the Commission typically takes dedication decision under Article 9 of Regulation 1/2003. This really is frequently a key to restoring effective competition for that market. Under commitment decisions, the Commission need not demonstrate an breach within the antitrust rules and imposes no fines. It voices its concerns and parties can come forward with commitments to deal with these concerns. When the Commission, after talking with promote participants, finds these commitments sufficient, it requires a choice to become legally binding.

The commitments are often valid for almost any specific time period however, once the companies breach them they could be fined.


A effective which has associated with anti-competitive conduct and for that reason infringed competition law might be vulnerable to fines enforced using the Commission under Regulation 1/2003. The Commission’s fining policy targets punishment and deterrence. The fines reflect the gravity and entire breach. They’re calculated underneath the framework of some Guidelines last revised around 2006.

The beginning point for the fine may be the volume of their annual sales within the product concerned within the breach (around 30%). Your particulars are often multiplied with this number and lots of days the breach lasted. The fine may be elevated (e.g. repeat offender) or decreased (e.g. limited participation). The maximum quantity of fine is fixed to 10% within the overall annual turnover in the organization.

Right of appeal

The parties vulnerable to a Commission decision possess the right to draw in the overall Court for cautious be annulled. Legal Court can cancel, decrease or increase the fine enforced using the Commission. Judgments within the General Court may be appealed prior to the Court of Justice using the unsuccessful party (so the Commission may also be an appellant). However, these attracts legal court of Justice are restricted to questions of law only.

Victims’ claims for damages

Any citizen or business which suffers harm as a result of breach within the EU competition rules must be titled to state compensation inside the party who caused it. Meaning the folks with competition law infringements will bring an undertaking for damages prior to the national courts.

Joint/collective dominance

It should be noted that categories of companies may also be held to obtain with each other dominant round the particular market, this can be more uncommon used.

Share this:
custom writing low cost
Order custom writing